Thank You, Buddy Amato.

Thank You, Buddy Amato.

What follows is my own opinion and reflects my personal feelings. It is not a statement representing any of the groups involved, and nothing I say should be construed as originating from said groups.

Everything was under control with this rescue, but Mr. Amato, who has no jurisdiction in Ocean County, decided to stick his nose in. The report on News 12 quoted him as saying “All the animals should have been removed. . .then you get them adopted. You don’t just leave them there.” Yes, Mr. Amato, simple as that. You take 44-plus cats, all sick, flea-infested, and emaciated, and easily fit them in a shelter that has only about a dozen cages. The shelter will find a way to fit them all in, even though they’re so antisocial that almost all of them need to be caged separately. The town council will feel so bad that they all need to be spayed and neutered, that the females that are too pregnant to be spayed will give birth to sick kittens that will need veterinary care, and that they’ll need other expensive treatments and individual attention before anyone would want to touch them, much less adopt them, that they’ll give the shelter all the money they need to rehabilitate and house the cats. And, after the shelter miraculously becomes larger and acquires at least ten more cage banks, people will pour in from all corners to adopt them, even though there were already plenty of good-looking, healthy cats being put to sleep after too long a time without being adopted. In fact, the shelter administration will get so much money, so much space, and so many clients, that they will no longer have to decide that a cat is too expensive to treat, or that one cat is more adoptable than another, and opt for euthanasia. Oh, no, every cat that comes in will be taken care of, no matter how much it costs, no matter how difficult it might be as a pet, and live out its days in comfort until it finds a home! Does it work that way in Monmouth County, Mr. Amato? Lucky you!

Unfortunately, it’s not that way in any town or county shelter I’ve ever heard of, and not that way in Toms River. That’s why the cats were going to be removed in stages by the rescue group. Tails With Happy Endings took out as many cats as they could house, and began getting them the veterinary care they needed, paying for it with its own funds, swallowing the costs for food, litter, bedding, additional cages. The idea was that since the town shelter would have had to put them all down, the rescue would take them in stages and get them adopted when they were healthy and well socialized, and the town would monitor the whole situation. Yes, it meant that some would be left in their same situation for a while longer, but they’d have a chance for a better life.

I doubt that Mr. Amato bothered to find this out before issuing his judgment. In fact, I doubt he bothered to find it out at all, because he apparently exerted his influence on certain officials of Toms River to have
Animal Control go back into the house and remove every single remaining animal.

In Buddy Amato Fantasy World, he’s a hero to these animals. Here where the rest of us live, their last memories before they die will be of having been captured ungently in a place of fear and filth. The shelter is already full of cats that have all their fur, that come forward in the cages to be petted rather than cowering and hissing, that are pretty and healthy and adoptable. None of them will be displaced by the “rescued” cats. Perhaps being dead is a better alternative to living the way they did, but it’s not a better alternative to the way the first batch will end up – the way they, too, would have ended up if Mr. Amato hadn’t swooped in to save the day. Bravo, sir.

Of course, now that the town doesn’t have to spend anything to care for all these animals, maybe they can purchase a vehicle for the same purpose. Outfit it with multiple gas chambers, capture animals in crates that fit right in, cold storage in the back, and they don’t even have to go back to the shelter. It could say in big letters along the sides “Buddy Amato Mobile Euthanasia Truck,” so he could get the recognition he deserves.

  • tamera

    I’m familiar with the case and Buddy was proactively contacted by the reporter to ask what WOULD happen in Monmouth county if the situation had happened there? He was contacted…he didn’t stick his nose in first.

    Buddy Amato doesn’t make the laws, he merely follows and enforces them. The man does more good for animals in one day than the majority of people who talk but show no action. Surely you’re aware that he’s the guy who broke the cat killer case in Aberdeen? Buddy got him the longest sentence possible, you can see for yourself at http://independent.gmnews.com/news/2008/1211/front_page/014.html .

    Buddy deserves a hell of a lot of recognition for all the good stuff he does with animals. I’m really sorry you feel otherwise and feel the need to slam him. Talk to him instead.

  • http://www.alisonblogs.com Alison

    That’s a fine justification for having answered the News12 reporter, but does not explain why he went out of his district to demand removal of the cats, nor does it absolve him of responsibility for not finding out what arrangements had actually been made (which, BTW, Mayor Kelaher should have done, as well.)

    Based on the fact that he has gotten plenty of press, I don’t think the problem is a dearth of recognition for the good stuff he does. The problem is that doing a lot of good doesn’t give you a free pass to do something else that isn’t. I’m glad that he’s helped animals in the past, but these animals certainly did not benefit.

    If he had bothered to find out what arrangements had been made, these cats would still be alive. The progress that has been made with the ones who were removed by TWHE is amazing, and the others could have benefited in the same way in their turn.

    I did make one mistake in my post – not all the animals were removed. One room still has some cats, and the homeowners have managed to keep some dogs hidden. So it was only a dozen or so cats that were removed, but it’s still a dozen or so that will never know what it’s like to be healthy, clean, and loved.

    If I were unconnected with this, I would certainly have contacted Mr. Amato – any consequences of speaking my mind would be mine alone to bear. However, the need to preface anything I say with a disclaimer to protect the innocent limits my options. Here, the entire context is available to the public, so anything taken out of that context can be shown to be part of one person’s opinion, and harder to misconstrue as a representative statement of any organization.